Santa Clara River Estuary Special Studies
The City of Ventura is bordered by the Santa Clara River to the south and the Ventura River to the north.
Current Information
Stakeholder Meetings I Reports I Items Of Interest
Santa Clara River Special Studies Overview
In order to keep our community safe and healthy, Ventura’s Water Reclamation Facility (VWRF) treats the wastewater generated by the City’s 30,000 homes and businesses to stringent standards before releasing the clean water to the Santa Clara River Estuary (Estuary). This water is regulated with a permit issued by the Los Angeles Regional Water Quality Control Board (RWQCB), which is renewed every five years. During the 2008 re-issuance process, controversy arose on whether or not the City should be permitted to continue its current volume of water released into the Estuary.
While some parties wanted the RWQCB to revoke the existing exemption to State water policy, which allows the discharge, others, including resource agencies such as NOAA Fisheries and California Department of Fish and Game, did not want any decrease in the amount of the current discharge until all alternatives were evaluated thoroughly to allow for the best ecologically sustainable alternative since the discharge supports the Estuary’s endangered species and enhancement of its habitat value.
Therefore, the Discharge Permit issued by the RWQCB allowed continuation of the discharge but required Ventura Water to perform three extensive studies which include:
The special studies along with the associated stakeholder processes are designed to provide information necessary to support development of a sustainable discharge regime. In the end, these studies will result in the issuance of a Discharge Permit for the future that will allow the City to utilize its recycled water as a valuable resource, balancing this benefit with the additional environmental benefits of sustaining the critical habitat for endangered species in the Estuary.
Ongoing Efforts and Next Steps
In April 2009, the City hired the consulting team of Carollo Engineers and Stillwater Sciences to perform the special studies. The consulting team spent several months collecting data to determine what information was missing in order to create a monitoring plan to addresses needed information. The missing information is summarized below in the Estuary Subwatershed Study Data Gaps Table. The Final Estuary Monitoring Plan is available below for review.
A series of five workshops were held from 2009 to February 2011, in which the results of the three studies were discussed. The Recycled Water Market Study and the Treatment Wetlands Feasibility Study were submitted to the RWQCB in March 2010 as required by the NPDES permit. The submitted reports are available as links below.
Interconnect Option Feasibility Study Underway
Kennedy Jenks Consultants is currently preparing a feasibility study for another option that incorporates regional benefits: discharging treated effluent from the VWRF to the City of Oxnard’s Advanced Water Purification Facility (AWPF). The desalted water is envisioned to provide beneficial reuse as a seawater intrusion barrier through groundwater injection as well as reuse for irrigation. This option will also include investigating discharge to the City of Oxnard’s ocean outfall and/or the Salinity Management Pipeline being constructed by Calleguas Municipal Water District. All three interconnection locations are within the same general vicinity. This alternative would require approximately 10 miles of pipeline to transport treated effluent from the VWRF to the interconnect location(s) in Oxnard. This alternative has the potential to provide Ventura Water and other local agencies with regional groundwater benefits and may have lower operation and maintenance costs when compared to other alternatives to reuse the treated water.
Participant Resources
Related Reports
- 2009 Wastewater Annual Report Anaylsis (PDF, 17.5 MB)
- Recycled Water Market Study - Phase 1 Final Report - March 2010 (PDF, 1.5 MB)
- Wetlands Feasibility Study - Phase 1 Final Report - March 2010 (PDF 2 MB)
- Year One Data Summary & Assessment - January 2010
- Enhancement Study
- Metals Translator Study
- Resident Species Study
Santa Clara Estuary Phase 2 Studies
- FINAL REPORT - Estuary Special Studies Phase 2 (pdf)
- Phase 2 Hydrology Data (pdf)
- Phase 2 Water Quality Data July 2012 (pdf)
- Phase 2 Water Quality Data Sept 2012 (pdf)
- Phase 2 Water Quality Monthly Analytical (pdf)
- Phase 2 Water Quality Monthly Insitu (pdf)
- Selected Flows to Estuary Chart (jpeg)
- Selected Alternatives Table (jpeg)
Final Santa Clara River Estuary Subwatershed Study
- Amended Final Report - Santa Clara River Estuary Subwatershed Study - September 2011 (pdf - 9 MB)
- Response to Stakeholder Comments & Clarification of RWQCB Comments Re: Enhancement (pdf 205 KB)
- Recommendations for Phase 2 - Draft Memorandum (pdf 65 KB)
- Final Santa Clara River Estuary Subwatershed Study - March 6, 2011 (pdf - 9 MB)
-
Appendix B - Water Quality and Benthic Macroinvertebrates Data Compilation
- Compiled VWRF Annual Reports (pdf)
- Compiled Annual Benthic Macroinvertebrate Data For Santa Clara River Estuary (pdf)
- Compiled grab sample data for Santa Clara River Estuary (xls)
- 2009-2010 Continuous in situ water quality data for Santa Clara River Estuary (xls)
-
2009-2010 Laboratory Report
- SEM Laboratory Reports Spreadsheet (xls)
- SEM Laboratory Reports Detailing Nutrient Conc. from Estuary (SCRE) and Groundwater (GW) 2009-10
Comments to Final Estuary Subwatershed Study
The Los Angeles Regional Water Quality Control Board approved the extension of comments to the March 6, 2011 Final Report to July 15, 2011.
The following are comment letters received by Ventura Water.
- Heal the Bay (pdf)
- Ventura Audubon Society (pdf)
- Ventura Coastkeeper (pdf)
- Ventura Coastkeeper Third Party Experts (pdf)
- Fish & Wildlife Service (pdf)
- Surfrider Foundation (pdf)
- Dr. Elise Kelley (pdf)
- Ventura Coastkeeper Third Party Experts - Second Set of Comments (pdf)
- National Marine Fisheries Service (pdf)
- Ventura Coastkeeper Third Party Experts - Third Set of Comments (pdf)
- Ventura Audubon Society (pdf)
Event Information
Stakeholder Meetings:
February 21, 2013 stakeholder meeting materials:
- Agenda for Feb 21 Workshop (pdf)
- Feb 21 Workshop Notes (pdf)
- Feb 21 Slide Presentation (pdf)
- Selected Flows to Estuary Chart (jpeg)
- Selected Alternatives Table (jpeg)
- Feb 21 Stakeholder Attendee List (pdf)
- Draft Phase 2 Report (pdf 21,412KB)
- Phase 2 Hydrology Data (pdf)
- Phase 2 Water Quality Data July 2012 (pdf)
- Phase 2 Water Quality Data Sept 2012 (pdf)
- Phase 2 Water Quality Monthly Analytical (pdf)
- Phase 2 Water Quality Monthly Insitu (pdf)
October 31, 2012 stakeholder meeting materials:
- Agenda for Oct 31 Workshop (pdf)
- Oct 31 Slide Presentation (pdf)
- Oct 31 Stakeholder Attendee List (pdf)
- Ventura County Star Article - 11/1/2012 (pdf)
- Oct. 31 Workshop Notes (pdf)
July 18, 2012 stakeholder meeting materials:
- Agenda for July 18 Workshop (pdf)
- July 18 Workshop Notes (pdf)
- July 18 Stakeholder Attendee List (pdf)
- July 18 Slide Presentation (pdf)
- Breakout Group Alternative Worksheets (pdf)
In addition, several people were interested in the CDPH powerpoint slides. The draft regulations and associated background documents, including several CDPG presentations, can be found at:
http://www.cdph.ca.gov/healthinfo/environhealth/water/pages/waterrecycling.aspx
August 18, 2011 stakeholder meeting materials:
- Agenda for August 18 Workshop (pdf)
- Aug. 18 Workshop Notes (pdf)
- Aug. 18 Stakeholder Attendee List (pdf)
- Aug. 18 Slide Presentation (pdf)
February 10, 2011 stakeholder meeting materials:
- Agenda for Feb. 10 Workshop (pdf)
- Feb. 10 Workshop Notes (pdf)
- Feb. 10 Stakeholder Attendee List (pdf)
- Feb. 10 Slide Presentation (pdf)
- Administrative Draft - Estuary Subwatershed Study Synthesis Report - February 2011 (pdf - 6.72 MB)
Sept. 28, 2010 stakeholder meeting materials:
- Agenda for Sept. 28 Workshop (pdf)
- Sept. 28 Stakeholder Attendee List (pdf)
- Sept. 28 Slide Presentation (pdf)
-
Sept. 28 Workshop Notes (pdf)
Feb. 2, 2010 stakeholder meeting materials:
- Feb. 2 Stakeholder Attendee List
- Feb. 2 Presentation
- Feb. 2 Workshop Notes
- Agenda for Feb. 2 workshop (pdf)
- Draft Year One Data Summary and Assessment, January 2010 (pdf - 2.6MB)
- Draft Recycled Water Market Study, Phase 1 Report, January 2010 (pdf - 8.1MB)
- Draft Treatment Wetlands Feasibility Study Report, January 2010 (pdf - 9.1MB)
Nov. 10, 2009 stakeholder meeting materials:
- Agenda for Nov. 10 workshop (pdf)
- Nov. 10 Stakeholder list (pdf)
- Nov. 10 Presentation (pdf)
- Nov. 10 Workshop Notes (pdf)
July 15, 2009 stakeholder meeting materials:
Order/Permit Documentation
Ventura Water is currently discharging up to 14 million gallons per day of tertiary treated wastewater from the Ventura Water Reclamation Facility, under an order/permit from the Los Angeles Regional Water Quality
Control Board which includes:
- Waste Discharge Requirements Package
- Attachment G & H
- Attachment I
- Attachment K
- Attachment L
- Attachment M (Summer)
- Attachment M (Winter)
- Attachment N
For More Information
If you are interested in participating, or have questions regarding information posted on this website, please contact Karen Waln at kwaln@cityofventura.net.